Selling a Home in Merrick, NY
Overview
Merrick is a South Shore hamlet in the Town of Hempstead. Its neighborhoods south of Merrick Road sit along canals with access to the bays, while the streets to the north offer established residential blocks close to shopping on Merrick Road and Sunrise Highway.
Evan Mogelefsky and The Mogelefsky Team at Douglas Elliman Real Estate are based at 2300 Merrick Rd, in the heart of town.
Getting Around
The Merrick station on the LIRR Babylon Branch offers service toward Penn Station and Grand Central Madison. Sunrise Highway and Merrick Road run east to west through town, and the Meadowbrook State Parkway connects to the Southern State Parkway to the north and Jones Beach to the south.
Lifestyle
Norman J. Levy Park and Preserve offers walking trails and wide views over the marshes and bay. Merrick Road Park Golf Course is close by, and boaters use the canals to reach the bays. Merrick Road and the area around the train station have local restaurants, cafes, and shops.
Where to Eat and Shop in Merrick
A few local favorites for dining out:
Salt on the Water, 3100 Whaleneck Dr: seafood with waterfront views.
Fabio's Restaurant, 1944 Bayberry Ave: Italian dining and bar.
La Piazza, 2191 Merrick Rd: Italian restaurant and pizzeria.
Sufiya's Grill: Persian and Mediterranean cuisine.
Sushi Ko, 57A Merrick Ave: sushi, with dinner reservations recommended.
For food shopping:
A&S Fine Foods, 2162 Merrick Rd: Italian specialty market and full butcher shop, with homemade mozzarella and sausage.
Sweet & Salty Ride Bakery, 2071 Merrick Rd: cookies, pastries, breads, and custom cakes, baked fresh daily.
Trader Joe's, 1714 Merrick Rd.
Stop & Shop, 2160 South Merrick Mall: full-service supermarket.
Homes
Merrick's homes range from colonials, capes, high ranches, and split-levels to custom new construction. South of Merrick Road, many homes sit on the water with bulkheads and docks, and some have been elevated or rebuilt in recent years.
Schools
Merrick is served by the following public school districts. The district for a specific home depends on its address, so confirm with the district before buying or listing.
Merrick Union Free School District (elementary grades)
North Merrick Union Free School District (elementary grades)
Bellmore-Merrick Central High School District (grades 7 to 12)
Links go to independent ratings and data on GreatSchools.
The Market
In September 2026, 26 single-family homes sold in Merrick at a median price of $980,000, in a median of 17 days on market. 17 of 26 sold at or above asking price, and the median sold price per square foot was $529.
Source: OneKey MLS, September 2026. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
For a broader view, Zillow's Home Value Index puts the typical Merrick home value at $905,208, up 5.7% from a year earlier, with homes going under contract in about 21 days. This is Zillow's estimate across all homes, not actual sale prices. Source: Zillow, data through July 31, 2026.
Selling Tips
Waterfront sellers should gather bulkhead records, dock permits, an elevation certificate, and any flood history before listing, since buyers and their insurers will ask. For every home, pricing from recent sales on your own street or canal, rather than town-wide averages, is what protects your bottom line.
Thinking of selling? Call or text Evan Mogelefsky at 516-322-7518 or his office at 516-623-2777 for a private consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
How quickly are homes selling in Merrick?
In September 2026, Merrick homes sold in a median of 17 days, and 17 of 26 sold at or above asking price (Source: OneKey MLS).
What should I prepare before selling a waterfront home in Merrick?
Have your bulkhead and dock records, permits, elevation certificate, and flood history ready. New York requires sellers to disclose known flood history.
Which LIRR station serves Merrick?
The Merrick station on the Babylon Branch.
Which school districts serve Merrick?
Merrick Union Free School District and North Merrick Union Free School District for elementary grades, and Bellmore-Merrick Central High School District for grades 7 to 12. The district depends on the home's address.
Who can help me sell my home in Merrick?
Evan Mogelefsky of The Mogelefsky Team at Douglas Elliman Real Estate is based in Merrick and has sold Long Island homes for more than 20 years. Call or text 516-322-7518.
Comments